Love Island: Did Producers Rig the Vote to Stop Casey's Annual Villa Return?

The recent 'Love Island: All Stars' finale saw Gabby Allen and Casey O'Gorman crowned winners, a result that sparked debate among viewers. Some fans are suggesting the producers may have subtly influenced the outcome to prevent Casey from returning to the villa for a fourth time. Casey's multiple appearances on 'Love Island,' including the original version in 2023 and 'All Stars' in both 2024 and 2025, have become a running joke. Social media users playfully accused the show of being "rigged," theorizing that producers awarded Casey the win to discourage future appearances. "Love Island had to crown Casey the winner - they didn't want him back in the Summer," one fan quipped on X (formerly Twitter). Others echoed this sentiment, suggesting the win was a strategic move to keep him away from the villa. Whether this theory holds true remains to be seen, but Casey's victory has certainly stirred up conversation among 'Love Island' enthusiasts.